Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Julie Peller's avatar

I very much appreciate your valuable insights and analyses. Thank you for taking the time to communicate important topics with others.

Expand full comment
Nicholas Pretzel's avatar

You would know far better than I, so please correct me if I'm wrong, but it seems to me that we (human beings) have a tendency to focus and remember the negative more than the positive. I've long believed that as a species we are more good than bad, that we are a social and cooperative animal rather than a competitive one. After all, we have empathy (not that we're unique in that respect, but it doesn't appear to be a common characteristic) and we hate to see suffering and injustice. We care, not just about ourselves and our closest relatives and friends, but for all humans and beyond, for all life. There are millions of small acts of kindness that happen every day, but they largely go unnoticed. This is what I mean about focussing on the negative. Good news isn't considered newsworthy. Unpleasant experiences seem to affect us for longer and have a greater effect on us than pleasant ones. From an evolutionary perspective that makes sense: we wish to avoid the unpleasant experiences in the future, remembering and focussing on them helps us do that. If it is indeed the case that we are biased towards the negative then it's valuable and important to be reminded of our better side, so thank you for doing that. There are many things we have to be proud of: music, science, the arts (sorry, I'm a musician and almost certainly biased in that respect; I think it's one of our greatest achievements as well as profoundly mysterious. Several years ago BBC Radio 4 asked 100 scientists what the most interesting question in science was for an end-of-year poll. One physicist replied with “Why do we like music?” I'd never given it much thought but it's intrigued me ever since).

As for diversity, I remember reading or hearing somewhere that we have one of the narrowest gene pools of any species and that's not good. It's just one reason diversity is important and should be encouraged, why people of mixed race are good for us. Having said that, I also remember reading that there's no genetic basis for race, that it's not possible to tell what race someone is from their DNA. Perhaps you'd be good enough to correct me if either of those facts are inaccurate (i.e. that they aren't facts; I've always had a problem with ‘alternative facts’. A fact is a fact, if there's a valid alternative then it isn't a fact).

Anyway, thank you again for going to the effort to write ‘The Antidote’ and reporting on our positive and worthy qualities.

Expand full comment
29 more comments...

No posts